um twilight the book versus harry potter:p

[saniya]

haha i dunno why i am starting this but i guess i just want u all to have a healthy argument and have fun;)


i aint sayin much as i am lazy at the moment hehe

[Parina]

twilight~!
i havent read harry potter, but watched a few movies (unwillingly -.-) and i just dont like it. the plot, the characters. maybe the books are different from the movies but doesnt change my opinon i think, i love the twilight saga xD

[Aethon]

I haven't understood peoples random obsession, nor have I understood the random hatred for Twilight. To me, it's just a good read, that just to happens to be another vampire book. So-the-fuck-what if she did it different than normal, and wtf is there to obsess over? They're imaginary characters people... not real, you'll never have them.

PS: Cedric Digory =/= Edward Cullen

[Cross Croccifixio]

Let me tell you a little something about Twilight (This is directed at all people who like Twilight)

Twilight was a piece of shit written on toilet and scribed by the given author. (To me anyways. =P)

Harry Potter has more language capacity than Twilight to the power of 50,000, and it's friggin' awesome.

So, therefore I conclude, Twilight fails
Harry Potter wins in default.

End of discussion.

~ Cruciare

[Blue Marble]

Let me tell you a little something about Twilight (This is directed at all people who like Twilight)

Twilight was a piece of shit written on toilet and scribed by the given author. (To me anyways. =P)

Harry Potter has more language capacity than Twilight to the power of 50,000, and it's friggin' awesome.

So, therefore I conclude, Twilight fails
Harry Potter wins in default.

End of discussion.

~ Cruciare
^ My thoughts as well, pretty much.

[Seijuro]

I like vampire movie books shows etc. But twilight was shit. The love story had no build all of sudden oh we are in love share all my secrets. I am a harry potter fan. The movies are crap though you have to read the books. Personally this should be comparing like eragon or stardust or even inkheart with harry potter. Movies/Books that were actually good. Though the first book in eragon was little immaturely written. but the next two have been good now that the author isnt 15.

[rasenshuriken]

I like vampire movie books shows etc. But twilight was shit. The love story had no build all of sudden oh we are in love share all my secrets. I am a harry potter fan. The movies are crap though you have to read the books. Personally this should be comparing like eragon or stardust or even inkheart with harry potter. Movies/Books that were actually good. Though the first book in eragon was little immaturely written. but the next two have been good now that the author isnt 15.

^this

[Cross Croccifixio]

I don't even know why the author of "Twilight" even write the shitty piece of paper.

[p4091a]

Harry potter wins.

But only because twilight was simply too bad to be true.
It was bad writing. Just baaad.
It's not just about the fangirling, or about the sparkling vamps anymore.
The writing.
It's bad.

http://otahyoni.livejournal.com/130432.html

Go read it.
And ask yourself. How can it be anything but bad?

[Jakkin]

They both suck. But if I was to choose one, HP is more entertaining...